Virtual Scholars
An imagined form of scholarship…Archive for December, 2008
Snowflakes Keeping Falling on my Head…

A rare vision: R. sent me this image, something he submitted to a competition. It is perhaps a little too small to see here, but the upper half of the building has his characteristic cladding design (in ‘apple’ white). I felt, given the festive season, it might be thought of as a modern snowflake…
Willy Wonka’s Turner Prize!

Martin and I got to the Turner Prize just a few days before Mark Leckey was announced the winner. Leckey has been ’[d]escribed as a “modern-day dandy” and is known for exhibitions combining sculpture, film and performance, many referencing pop culture icons such as the Simpsons and Felix the Cat’ (The Guardian). Interestingly, whilst based in London, he is a part-time film studies professor at Frankfurt’s Staedelschule. Having won the prize and received the £25,000 cheque, he said because of the credit crunch he would hide the money somewhere safe and hoped a TV channel would enlist him to make his own variety programme, ‘like the Two Ronnies. But with art’. That would be something.
A perspex sculpture, ‘curated’ by Goshka Macuga.
But, by the time I got to the room of Leckey’s work a certain fatigue had set in. The openning room is of Goshka Macuga’s work – or rather other artists’ work which she then ‘curates’. On the Tate’s website she is described as merging ‘the roles of collector, curator and artist, creating carefully staged, mixed-media installations which draw on the conventions of the historical archive and exhibition making’ (Turner Prize). There was something satisfying about the room - an air of calm and intelligence. The art of curating has been on my mind recently – including ‘A Thousand Words’, curated by Tracy Chevalier at the York Art Gallery, which includes a blackboard-style border running around the whole gallery, inviting visitors to write down their own thoughts and ideas with chalk. The idea of making existing artworks ‘do’ something and to generate an exhibition out of an idea, rather than simply the work itself is intriguing. [Watch this space]
The next room had a work by Cathy Wilkes. I found myself reading the wall text before even looking into the room. It read very well, something like the following on the Tate’s website: ‘Cathy Wilkes’s installations of objects, readymades and paintings are formally precise and contemplative. Their essentially diaristic and self-reflective forms are composed using a complex and liberated visual language. Her work, whilst in many ways uncompromisingly introspective, is characterized by direct, almost diagrammatic invocations of daily human experience’ (Turner Prize). Martin and I then turned slowly to see the room and then turned slowly to look at each other. Then the uncontrollable laughter. Ill-conditioned shop mannequins were perched upon redundant supermarket checkouts and scattered about the place were bits and pieces of just stuff – various junk items piled here and there. It was dreary and lacked any of the verve of the written text. It was no better than the sort of stuff I see at a graduation show – in fact, given the spotlight it was worse!

Be The First To see What You see As You see It (Runa Islam, 2004).
We then moved on to film and video artist Runa Islam. As we entered this darkened area we moved into an alcove to read the wall text (which was bathed in a warm light). As we moved into this space a phone was ringing. Without us realising, a woman moved in front of use to take a call. Suddenly we were all bunched up in the alcove, a spotlight upon us and an uncomfortable feeling that we were deep inside this women’s private world! We quickly retreated and tried desparately to contain the laughter (Martin had initally thought it all part of the work!). Finally we settled to watch the three video works by Islam.
Runa Islam is fascinated by the ability of film to capture something existing beyond physical space. Her film installations explore the content and apparatus of film, exposing its technical processes to reveal the inherently illusory nature of the medium, yet preserving its magic. They assert that the internal and external codes of cinema cannot be separated. Location, action, shot and installation, apparatus and dialogue with the viewer are all agents in the production of light and illusion. She carefully choreographs these elements in open ended, counter narrative frameworks and composed installations that are conceptually based but at the same time emotionally charged. Whilst visually lyrical, underwritten by their conceptual foundations they are an investigation into the technology of film and the possibilities of representation. (Turner Prize)
For once the text seemed to match with the visuals. Islam’s work is both analytical and captivating. I think I’d like to have seen her win, but somehow I knew she wouldn’t. Especially when, in a slight daze from the darkened rooms of Islam’s work, I emerged into the final room with Leckey’s work.
It was a bit like entering into a moment of Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. There was the same sense of playfulness, maverick invention and basic silliness. Given that the prize has been considered ‘dull’ this year (and generally left unreported), it seemed obvious to me that Leckey would win. He was the closest they had to a Turner Prize winner. But, I had had my filled by then. I watched some of the video playing of Leckey giving a ‘lecture’ on art, and it was good (his ‘material’ use of language is great), but essentially it was predictable.

We then went to see paintings by Turner (which I haven’t seen for years). We didn’t take in much as we were beginning to talk about all sorts of things. But, on the way we saw some wonderful drawings, all part of an exhibit, Drawn from the Collection (400 years of British drawing). In the bookshop was a fairly recent book about drawing by John Berger (including some correspondence with James Elkins). I wished I’d bought it now.
For an informed and patient view of the Turner Prize 2008, see Nick Hackworth’s two Tate Shots films (and then perhaps cast your vote below!)…
Tate Shots: Goshka Macuga and Cathy Wilkes


Virtual Feed
